LAST EDITED ON 28-Jul-10 AT 02:39 PM (PST)
Here's a user review from Yelp with more good info on Gem Spa and egg creams in general:
If you were to ask a kid in New York during the late 1800s through the late 1960s what their favorite drink was, an egg cream would certainly be the most popular answer. However, if you were to ask a kid nowadays what an egg cream was, they'd probably think it was a Cadbury product or just look at you blankly and turn up their iPod. What a shame.
An egg cream is a three-ingredient wonder-a drink that was once a delicate, step-laden mainstay at soda fountains throughout New York, but is now a piece of food history. Not at Gem Spa in St. Mark's Place off 2nd avenue, however. When you look at Gem Spa, which is a magazine/tobacco corner store, it doesn't exactly scream "egg cream"-and if not for the self-titled "New York's best egg cream" printed on its canopy, it would be safe to assume that they didn't make anything of the sort. Despite the oddity of the situation, you just have to accept it at face value, and give them a shot.
One of the first great aspects of an egg cream is that there is no egg or cream used in one. No one is really sure how it got its name, though it is possible the very first version did include the now ironically defunct ingredients. The other vital aspect is that despite the three simple ingredients-chocolate or vanilla syrup, seltzer, and whole milk-if mixed incorrectly, the end result will be lackluster. Since seltzer no longer comes in the high-intensity spritzer bottles, the necessary fizz and foamy head are often absent from modern-day attempts. However, since Gem Spa has all the proper machinery, they are a egg cream powerhouse.
The question now becomes, "How did Gem Spa decide to vend egg creams despite being a normal-looking corner store?" Apparently, the "new" owner of Gem Spa purchased the storefront over 30 years ago from a man who was known for his egg creams. Upon selling the store, the old owner taught the new one the magic behind the egg cream-and left the traditional equipment for it too. It's all there-a syrup dispenser, a high-intensity seltzer spout, and a milk frother.
Even though the recipe has exchanged hands, and been in use for at least half a century, it's still a top secret at Gem Spa. It's so much of a secret, that the gentleman behind the counter instructed me not to take a picture of the egg cream making process-though he did let me take a picture of the finished product. The end result was perfection. When the bubbles hit my lips, I was no longer standing on the corner of a busy, touristy section of 2nd avenue, but instead I was transformed back fifty-plus years. How often can you experience that?
Egg Cream Price: $2.50